=====
From chipr@niestu.com:
Excellent image, very wistful mood.  Good feeling of depth.

=====
From sroberts@learn.senecac.on.ca:
What an exceptionally well-done scene!  Extremely well-rendered, great attention to detail, very realisitc in appearance...high marks.
=====
From m-kolb@uiuc.edu:
The fallng snow needs a little help -- it looks perhaps a little too much like 
a 'bozo' texture. However, I think your interior is great, and I really like
the frost effects on the windows. I've given your image some of the highest 
markings out of the images I've seen so far. Nice job!
- Michael J. Kolb

=====
From jay@map.com:
Wow!  Not much I can pick at in this image.  The wood grain on the desk (and perhaps the far wall) seems a bit large, but in no way detracts from the overall picture.  Well done!


=====
From cgallego@nordnet.fr:

Nice work... Beware of the lights.

http://home.nordnet.fr/~cgallego


=====
From tholal@bga.com:
Excellent job with the snow. I like the frost effect also.

=====
From bill.marrs@pureatria.com:
Nice depth (all the way back to the chair and floor lamp!)  icicles was a nice
touch too - a form of "Glass" that I hadn't considered.

=====
From tlyons@gnn.com:
how did you do the falling snow?

=====
From 93semeno@scar.utoronto.ca:
The only image I gave perfect score to. I am amazed by how such realism is achieved with such simplicity. I also love the melancholy mood of the scene. Great job!

=====
From tiger@mgl.ca:
Actually.. it's 'poetic license'.. not to be anal or picky or anything :)
I like this image.


=====
From ucoakc00@mcl.ucsb.edu:
Another beautiful image. I'm impressed with the attention you pay to detail.


=====
From danclegg@uniserve.com:
Lots of work.

=====
From rea@st-and.ac.uk:
Good.   A tip for icicles is to use a lot of ripples, since mostly they
are so bumpy as to prevent any clear refraction at all.

=====
From jmills@stic.net:
Awesome! The cracks and chips in the paint really make this image stand out!

=====
From amarok@geocities.com:
Thumbs up!

=====
From bsieker@techfak.uni-bielefeld.de:
Very nice! I especially like the wispy snow on the windows themselves.

=====
From ptdawson@voicenet.com:
Nice tree! 8-) Really, *everything* in the scene is excellent.

=====
From lpurple@netcom.com:
I like it, just like the orbital bedroom earlier; it uses the glass to form a
powerful barrier between two very different realms. Nice job on the snowflakes. 


From web_user@tonyv.aztec.co.za:
I like this one. The snow looks good. But then, I live in a part of the world where snow is not seen!
Notable for composition, textures, modelling