=====
From joheriks@abo.fi:

Not really an improvement over the other one. I just averaged out my ratings over the two entries.
=====
From rich@brickbots.com:
See my previous comments.  The extra light helps.
=====
From hildurka@simnet.is:
The concept is nice but the image is way too dark. 
Difficult to see anything. 

=====
From dungbeatle@mail.tds.net:
A little too dark for me.
=====
From simon_smith@zen.co.uk:

The wet rope in the foreground (well I assume it's a rope) is too shiny. It's so bright it almost looks like a rendering error to me.



=====
From file:
nice use of lighting and theme.  what are the blue and white barber-type things?  they seem out of place, and detract from the realism due to graininess.