PuTTY wish dedicated-sharing-upstream

This is a mirror. Follow this link to find the primary PuTTY web site.

summary: Separate dedicated utility to act as connection sharing upstream
class: wish: This is a request for an enhancement.
difficulty: tricky: Needs many tuits.
priority: medium: This should be fixed one day.

The current PuTTY support for connection sharing works on the more or less ad-hoc basis that the first PuTTY or Plink to connect to a host becomes the 'upstream' (which manages the real SSH connection) and accepts connections from other PuTTY tools which automatically become 'downstreams' (talking to the upstream rather than to the real server).

A downside of this structure is that whichever PuTTY is first to contact a given host has to remain active while it's managing any connections from downstreams. This isn't a completely unfamiliar phenomenon to power users of SSH – it's exactly analogous to what happens when you end the terminal session in a PuTTY which still has X11 or port forwardings active – but it would be nicer to avoid it if possible, so that all visible PuTTYs behaved more or less similarly.

To arrange this, we'd have to have the first PuTTY spawn a separate process to act as a dedicated upstream. Then the PuTTY itself would connect to that, once it was ready, and merely be its first downstream.

This is a tricky project, perhaps as much work again as implementing connection sharing in the first place. Problems include:

How would SSH authentication work, if it needed to be interactive? One option would be to delegate the ssh-userauth protocol to the primary downstream (and pass it a special protocol message containing the cryptographic session ID for use in signatures).
Similarly, what about interactive elements of the transport protocol, such as host key verification or warnings about insecure primitives?
How would the user access the dedicated upstream process, to adjust its behaviour or emergency-terminate it? An obvious option is to have it open a little GUI icon in the system tray, but what if there isn't a system tray available (e.g. Unix PuTTY, run in a non-GUI context)? There might need to be a control protocol by which downstreams could talk to the dedicated upstream and tell it to change things.
What should the new utility be called? (Working title: pshare.)

If you want to comment on this web site, see the Feedback page.

Audit trail for this wish.

(last revision of this bug record was at 2013-11-17 14:08:16 +0000)