IETF STEERING GROUP (IESG) REPORT FROM THE IETF MEETING December 2nd, 1992 Reported by: Greg Vaudreuil, IESG Secretary This report contains IESG meeting notes, positions and action items. These minutes were compiled by the IETF Secretariat which is supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant No. NCR 8820945. For more information please contact the IESG Secretary. ATTENDEES --------- Almquist, Philip / Consultant Borman, David / Cray Research Hinden, Robert / SUN Knowles, Stev / FTP Software Piscitello, Dave/ Bellcore Vaudreuil, Greg / CNRI AGENDA ------ This special teleconference was called to restructure the IESG management of Lower Layer Working Groups. This re-organization was to address OSI Integration, Transport and Services, and Internet. MINUTES ------- The IESG agreed on a two step re-organization. The first step, the integration of OSI into other IESG areas will happen immediately. The second step, the split of Transport and Services and further Working Group re-alignments will be the basis for the selection of new IESG members and will take place in March. Several proposals were discussed. The OSI Integration was discussed previously and was re-affirmed. The creation of a new separate multi-protocol Internet Area was rejected as not meeting the intended goal of integrating other protocols into the Internet. The IETF is responsible for engineering the co-existence of other network protocols with IP and the interoperation issues with IP. Separating this function from the IP area was not felt to be an improvement. The Transport and Services area as now defined is a hybrid area created to meet the needs of the IETF given specific staffing. In order to select an appropriate Area Director, the area was split into two new areas reflecting the separate functions, Transport and Service Applications. Transport will encompass those protocols running over IP and protocols to be used by application protocols (RPC). Service Applications will encompass the applications which support host services, such as DNS, NTP, and Service Location. Below is the division of Working Groups and the staffing for each of the two phases of IESG re-organization. Phase 1 (Effective 12/7/92) Applications (Erik Huizer, Russ Hobby) ------------ Internet Mail Extensions (smtpext) Internet Message Extensions (822ext) Network Database (netdata) Network News Transport Protocol (nntp) Network Printing Protocol (npp) TELNET (telnet) MHS-DS (mhsds) MIME-MHS Interworking (mimemhs) OSI Directory Services (osids) Office Document Architecture (oda) X.400 Operations (x400ops) Internet (Steve Knowles, Dave Piscitello, Philip Almquist) -------- IP Address Encapsulation (ipae) IP over Asynchronous Transfer Mode (atm) P. Internet Protocol (pip) TCP/UDP over CLNP-addressed Networks (tuba) Dynamic Host Configuration (dhc) IP over AppleTalk (appleip) IP over FDDI (fddi) Multi-Media Bridging (mmb) Point-to-Point Protocol Extensions (pppext) Router Requirements (rreq) SNMP over a Multi-protocol Internet (mpsnmp) IP over Large Public Data Networks (iplpdn) Network Management (Chuck Davin) ------------------ Chassis MIB (Chassis) DS1/DS3 MIB (trunkmib) Host Resources MIB (hostmib) SNMP Version 2 (snmpv2) Token Ring Remote Monitoring (trmon) Uninterruptible Power Supply (upsmib) Bridge MIB (bridge) Ethernet MIB (ethermib) FDDI MIB (fddimib) IEEE 802.3 Hub MIB (hubmib) Internet Accounting (acct) X.25 Management Information Base (x25mib) Operational Requirements (Phill Gross, Bernhard Stockman) ------------------------ BGP Deployment and Application (bgpdepl) Benchmarking Methodology (bmwg) Network Joint Management (njm) Operational Statistics (opstat) User Connectivity (ucp) Network OSI Operations (noop) Routing (Bob Hinden) ------- OSI IDRP for IP over IP (ipidrp) RIP Version II (ripv2) Border Gateway Protocol (bgp) IP Routing for Wireless/Mobile Hosts (mobileip) ISIS for IP Internets (isis) Inter-Domain Policy Routing (idpr) Multicast Extensions to OSPF (mospf) Open Shortest Path First IGP (ospf) Security (Steve Crocker) -------- Network Access Server Requirements (nasreq) TCP Client Identity Protocol (ident) Commercial Internet Protocol Security Option (cipso) Common Authentication Technology (cat) Privacy-Enhanced Electronic Mail (pem) SNMP Security (snmpsec) Transport and Services (Dave Borman) ---------------------- Audio/Video Transport (avt) TCP Large Windows (tcplw) Distributed File Systems (dfs) Domain Name System (dns) Service Location Protocol (svrloc) Trusted Network File Systems (tnfs) User Services (Joyce Reynolds) ------------- Integration of Internet Information Resources (iiir) Networked Information Retrieval (nir) Universal Resource Identifiers (uri) Whois and Network Information Lookup Service (wnils) Directory Information Services Infrastructure (disi) Internet Anonymous FTP Archives (iafa) Internet School Networking (isn) Internet User Glossary (userglos) NOC-Tool Catalogue Revisions (noctool2) Network Information Services Infrastructure (nisi) User Documents Revisions (userdoc2) User Services (uswg) Phase 2 (After March Nominations) Note: Two of (Network Management, Security, Routing, User Services) needs to join to list of people to be put up for nomination.) Applications (Erik Huizer,?????) ------------ Internet Mail Extensions (smtpext) Internet Message Extensions (822ext) Network Database (netdata) Network News Transport Protocol (nntp) Network Printing Protocol (npp) TELNET (telnet) MHS-DS (mhsds) MIME-MHS Interworking (mimemhs) OSI Directory Services (osids) Office Document Architecture (oda) X.400 Operations (x400ops) Internet (??????, Dave Piscitello) -------- IP Address Encapsulation (ipae) IP over Asynchronous Transfer Mode (atm) P. Internet Protocol (pip) TCP/UDP over CLNP-addressed Networks (tuba) Dynamic Host Configuration (dhc) IP over AppleTalk (appleip) IP over FDDI (fddi) Multi-Media Bridging (mmb) Point-to-Point Protocol Extensions (pppext) Router Requirements (rreq) SNMP over a Multi-protocol Internet (mpsnmp) Network OSI Operations (noop) IP over Large Public Data Networks (iplpdn) Network Management (Chuck Davin) ------------------ Chassis MIB (Chassis) DS1/DS3 MIB (trunkmib) Host Resources MIB (hostmib) SNMP Version 2 (snmpv2) Token Ring Remote Monitoring (trmon) Uninterruptible Power Supply (upsmib) Bridge MIB (bridge) Ethernet MIB (ethermib) FDDI MIB (fddimib) IEEE 802.3 Hub MIB (hubmib) Internet Accounting (acct) X.25 Management Information Base (x25mib) Operational Requirements (????????, Bernhard Stockman) ------------------------ BGP Deployment and Application (bgpdepl) Benchmarking Methodology (bmwg) Network Joint Management (njm) Operational Statistics (opstat) User Connectivity (ucp) Routing (Bob Hinden) ------- OSI IDRP for IP over IP (ipidrp) RIP Version II (ripv2) Border Gateway Protocol (bgp) IP Routing for Wireless/Mobile Hosts (mobileip) ISIS for IP Internets (isis) Inter-Domain Policy Routing (idpr) Multicast Extensions to OSPF (mospf) Open Shortest Path First IGP (ospf) Security (Steve Crocker) -------- Network Access Server Requirements (nasreq) TCP Client Identity Protocol (ident) Commercial Internet Protocol Security Option (cipso) Common Authentication Technology (cat) Privacy-Enhanced Electronic Mail (pem) SNMP Security (snmpsec) Transport (??????) --------- Audio/Video Transport (avt) TCP Large Windows (tcplw) Service Applications (????????) -------------------- Distributed File Systems (dfs) Domain Name System (dns) Service Location Protocol (svrloc) Trusted Network File Systems (tnfs) OSI Directory Services (osids) User Services (Joyce Reynolds) ------------- Integration of Internet Information Resources (iiir) Networked Information Retrieval (nir) Universal Resource Identifiers (uri) Whois and Network Information Lookup Service (wnils) Directory Information Services Infrastructure (disi) Internet Anonymous FTP Archives (iafa) Internet School Networking (isn) Internet User Glossary (userglos) NOC-Tool Catalogue Revisions (noctool2) Network Information Services Infrastructure (nisi) User Documents Revisions (userdoc2) User Services (uswg)